Stage Whisper

AlbumDec 05 / 201119 songs, 1h 6m 1s
Indie Pop
Popular
6.8 / 10

This 2xCD splits itself between live recordings of songs from the French singer's most recent LPs and unreleased studio tracks, including two songs with Beck.

D+

The half-live, half-studio double-album Stage Whisper is the sort of overly padded stopgap release that record companies frequently trot out between proper albums. For the understated singer-songwriter Charlotte Gainsbourg, Whisper comes after 2009’s well-regarded IRM, and with just seven new songs (out of 19 tracks),…

7.3 / 10

The universe seems to be telling Charlotte Gainsbourg not to make music. All the ingredients for a doomed career are there.

A bit of a mixed bag.

Following the quietly brilliant IRM would be a tough act for almost any artist, so Charlotte Gainsbourg extends the afterglow of her second album a bit longer with this collection of previously unreleased songs and live tracks.

5.0 / 10

In both facets of her career, actress/singer Charlotte Gainsbourg has made a living bringing other people's visions to life.

More of a stop-gap than a proper fourth album, Charlotte Gainsbourg still manages to produce a few gems on Stage Whisper, writes <strong>Ally Carnwath</strong>

9 / 10

6 / 10

<p>A mixed bag of album outtakes and live recordings proves Gainsbourg sounds better in the studio than on stage, writes <strong>Rebecca Nicholson</strong></p>

60 %

8 / 10