Goths

AlbumMay 19 / 201712 songs, 55m 8s
Indie Pop Singer-Songwriter
Popular Highly Rated
8.0 / 10

John Darnielle's latest is a richly detailed collection of songs about the beautiful melancholy life of a goth, and the long journey between life in the dark and death in the light.

C

Goths, the Mountain Goats’ 16th studio album, opens with “Rain In Soho,” a barnburner of a song that belies the subdued nature of the tracks that follow. In fact, it gets things off to such a rousing start that it’s easy to overlook what’s missing—namely, frontman John Darnielle’s guitar. As mentioned in the album’s…

8 / 10

7 / 10

Goths feature heavily in a guitar-less departure from previous sonic territory.

7.5 / 10

"I'm hardcore/But I'm not that hardcore," a young man muses in the early chapters of the Mountain Goats' 2017 album, Goths, and in those seven words, group leader John Darnielle neatly summarizes the album's overriding theme: what it's like not to fit in, even among those folks who don't fit in.

9 / 10

Peter Hughes, longtime bassist of the Mountain Goats, describes the goth identity as one "most often associated with youth from a perspectiv...

8.0 / 10

Given John Darnielle's love of death metal, we knew Goths' day would come.

6 / 10

The Mountain Goats’s Goths focuses on the blurry boundary separating artistic success from failure.

9 / 10

6.0 / 10

Review of the Mountain Goats' Goths, there's a lot that works but does it outstay its welcome? The full-length comes out on May 19th, via Merge Records.