Pitchfork 7.6/10 The Bronx rapper’s full-length debut leans into a hard-nosed drill sound and features some of her most dynamic and abrasive bars to date.
NME 3/5 Rapper Ice Spice’s debut album ‘Y2K!’ is promising but uneven. It's unlikely to slow her rapid ascent – read the NME review
The Line of Best Fit 6/10 Y2K attempts new Ice Spice angles but ultimately it results in underbaked effort.
Evening Standard 3/5 Monotonous and broadly uninspiring production lets down the Bronx rapper’s debut
Rolling Stone 3.5/5 Ice Spice's 'Y2K' Review
The Independent 4/5 Following a wave of overlong albums, the cool, TikTokable concision of Ice Spice’s first full-length record feels effortlessly in control
Clash 7/10 Capricorns aren’t renowned as the zodiacs party animals. It’s right there in the symbolism: the sure and steady mountain goat. A sign split by New Year’s
The Observer 4/5 It’s all killer, no filler on the Bronx MC’s long-awaited debut album
Slant 3.5/5 The rapper’s debut album maintains a whirlwind clip throughout.
Pop Matters 7/10 Ice Spice's 'Y2K!' may have an obvious title, named for her birth year, but she wasn't born yesterday. In 2024, stating a fact is the realest thing you can do. 
The Guardian 3/5 The US star’s subject matter is lightweight and this debut album only lasts 23 minutes, but funny, snotty lines abound and the music is often viscerally exciting
The Telegraph 3/5 Rude lyrics and gale-force charisma are an amusing combination – but can they sustain a career?