Nine Track Mind

Pitchfork 2.5/10 The 24-year-old Berklee College of Music graduate and former YouTube star Charlie Puth has already had three top 40 singles, all since last February: The Meghan Trainor duet "Marvin Gaye", "See You Again" featuring Wiz Khalifa, and "One Call Away," an ocean of syrup that sounds exactly like "See You Again" and is the first song on Puth's debut LP.

The Observer 2/5 Puth’s solo debut is a huge disappointment

The Guardian 3/5 Charlie Puth maintains a consistently high standard of songwriting on his debut album